Sunday, November 2, 2008

Text Blog vs. Podcast

Podcasts

Pro-
  • Can use special effects, add music
  • Vocal emphasis that is lacking in written format (ie sarcasm)
  • Listening can be more interesting then reading a long text
  • Saves eyestrain from staring at computer screen
  • A good format to reach people with poor eyesight or who are blind
  • Gives a human element
  • Good for audio learners

Con-

  • Difficult to search the content without a transcription
  • poor audio quality can make it difficult to hear
  • Quality of speaker becomes more important, a dull monotone speaker will lose the audience
  • Uhhh, Ummmmm, You know
  • Some people are embarrassed to have their voice recorded
  • Some places it's not possible to listen to a podcast where it is possible to read (ie work)
  • Recording, rerecording, editing, uploading and then posting can take a long time

Text-based Blogging

Pro-

  • text is searchable
  • Just type and hit post. ~Spellcheck optional but encouraged ;D
  • Better for visual learners
  • Can read a blog places where you might not be able to listen to one
  • Easier for second language speakers (who can often understand written better then spoken)
  • eliminates difficultly understanding accents/dialects or speech problems
  • (See podcasting cons)

Con-

  • Potential misunderstandings due to lack of vocal cues
  • Difficult for those with spelling/writing disabilities
  • For some people it is easier to say something then to write it
  • (see podcasting pros)

No comments: